Nina Simone Live at Montreux Review

By Karin

Imagine my surprise when I was watching Bojack Horseman, the finale episode of Season 3, drowning in Bojack's existential crisis, as I heard a voice I’m sure I’ve heard hundreds of times by now: Nina Simone live at Montreux in 1976, singing a cover of Janis Ian’s “Stars.” A song about being famous — how hard people try, and the bad feelings that come with it. Simone suffered from bipolar disorder, and as bittersweet as the rendition may seem, her condition truly made this performance what it is. Simone did not write many of her own songs, but when she covered them, she certainly made them her own. As a jazz singer and classically trained pianist, Simone used her background to create new arrangements.

In 1959, Simone released her debut single, “I Loves You Porgy,” a cover from the 1935 opera Porgy and Bess. It made the Billboard Top 20, and her success began. Later in 1964, she became a big part of the Civil Rights Movement, writing protest songs like "Mississippi Goddam." Simone believed that the music industry was boycotting her records due to her involvement. Because of this, she moved to Barbados in 1970, followed by Liberia, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and eventually ended up in Paris by the late 1980s.

In 1976, Simone performed at the Montreux Jazz Festival in Switzerland. This was one of her four performances at the festival between 1968 and 1990. During the 1976 show, she of course sang “Stars,” but if I talk about that, I must also talk about her subsequent cover of “Feelings” by Morris Albert.

Before Simone starts her performance, she bows to the audience and claims she is a queen and laughs, “I know you are jolted because it occurs to you it might be true.” She begins “Stars,” almost immediately, stopping mid-lyric to yell at people to sit down. The audience seems uncomfortable, but she doesn’t seem to care. When she starts singing again — breath hitching, quiet, and distant — it seems as though she is suddenly overcome with emotion. About halfway through the song, she deviates from the original lyrics as though she forgot them. She says she's trying to tell a story, but it wasn’t what she meant to say. She ad-libs, paying homage to her influences and fellow artists, Janis Ian, Janis Joplin, and Billie Holiday, saying they all told the same story. She fades out on the repetitive lyric, “The latest story that I know is the one that I’m supposed to go out with.”

Simone jumps right into “Feelings” in a way that makes it seem like it could be the same song. She takes a quick pause after the first line to invite the audience to join her in the chorus. After singing just another line, she stops to say what a shame it must be to have to write such a sad song, and exclaims, “I do not believe the conditions that produced a situation to demand a song like that.” The audience, through all of this, is silent, and she reprimands them, asking them to clap. She begins again, this time with a regained sadness in her face. She turns to face the crowd and gets quiet in a way that invites them to sing with her, but they don’t. She goes deeper into the song, voice shaking like she is about to cry, pausing for a passion-filled piano break. Simone’s classical training really shines through here. It seems almost like she is making it up on the spot, and the feelings are just taking over. It is absolutely stunning. When she goes back to singing, she ad-libs again, saying she wishes she never lived this long. It’s truly heartbreaking. Voice shaking again with the crescendo of the piano, she asks the audience to join her again, but they don’t. I’d hope that the audience wasn’t participating because they were so shocked by her expression of emotion and talent. As Simone returns to the chorus, she blatantly asks them to join her. They finally comply, but do so quietly. She plays the piano for a while, shakes her head, and then ad-libs once more. This time it’s like a letter, talking directly to someone out there, saying, “You’ll always stay here in my heart, no matter what the words may say.” The end is done acapella until the lyrics' last two words, “for you,” that she sustains as she plucks at the piano. It’s blunt and robust. She plays two final chords, stands up, says goodnight, and leaves.

This is one of my favorite live performances, and I can’t even imagine what it was like to be in that audience and what they thought at that moment. I remember the first time I watched it. I had never seen a performance by Simone. I had listened to a couple of her songs, but this just came across my YouTube homepage one day, and I was intrigued. I was genuinely shocked by her musical talent. Her expressions invoked so much emotion within me that no other performance has replicated since. Simone had such a strong influence on music, and still does to this day, through her creativity and politics. She deserves much more credit than she is given. I think this performance is a must-watch, and all of her music is a must-listen.

- Karin